Shop Categories: Select a Category Baked Goods Adventure Cookies Valentine's Menu Book Boyfriend Collection Yeast & Legends Story Cakes Otherworldly Baked Tales Provisioner's Shelf Traveler's Biscotti Cocoa Chronicles Pancake Potions Whimsical Wares Accessories Kitchen Glassware Pet Apparel Care & Craft Baked Goods Whimsical Wares Care & Craft Sugarlore Baker's Choice Variety Pack $24.00 The Candygram - M&M Candy Cookie from $24.00 Pistachio Tree - Stuffed Pistachio Rose Cookie from $24.00 Catering Cookies - Party & Event Size $30.00 Noah Wilder – Malted Brown Butter Chocolate Chip with Walnuts from $24.00 Peppermint Hex - Peppermint Frosted Chocolate Sugar Cookie from $24.00 Cranberry Solstice - White Chocolate Cranberry Cookie from $24.00 Wonderland Way - Lemon Pistachio Biscotti Gift Set $14.00 Sugarlore Seasonal Variety Pack $30.00 Molasses Misadventures - Chewy Molasses Cookie from $24.00 Peppermint Pixie - Peppermint Cocoa Blend Gift Set $14.00 The Tesseract Incident - Blue Raspberry Sugar Cookie from $24.00 Sold Out Memoirs of a Monster - Ube White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie from $24.00 Autumn Orpington - Pumpkin Pecan Cinnamon Rolls $22.00 Sold Out Sweater Weather - Pumpkin Spice Latte from $10.00 Damien Hart – Dark Chocolate Espresso Cookie with Cayenne from $24.00 Salem Street - Traveller's Biscotti $8.00 The Dough Familiar $8.00 Witch's Brew - Double Cocoa Blend $8.00 Sold Out Golden Draught - Pancake Potion $8.00 Potion No. Chai - Pancake Potion $8.00 Butterbrew – Frosted Butterscotch Sugar Cookie from $24.00 Toffee Harvest – Brown Butter Toffee Pecan Cookie from $24.00 Sold Out Pumpkin Patch - Pumpkindoodle Cookie from $24.00 The Hearthbound Loaf - Sourdough Boule $12.00 Coco Calypso - Coconut Cream from $17.00 Spiced Hollows - Cookie Butter Stuffed Biscoff Cookie from $24.00 Fox's Folly - Reese's Peanut Butter Cookie from $24.00 Banani Stefani - Banana Cream Pie Cookie from $30.00 Wicked Woods - Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Cookie from $24.00 The Dark Side - Dark Chocolate Espresso from $20.00 Bread & Board: Sugarlore Sourdough Hotel from $0.00 Tuscany Trail - Traveller's Biscotti $8.00 Emerald Elixir - Pancake Potion $8.00 Fairy Fog - Earl Grey Lavender from $17.00 Cinnamon Queen - Cinnamon Rolls $22.00 Heart of the Forest - Pecan Cookie from $24.00 Fairest of Them All - Cheesecake $20.00 Love at First Zest - Lemon-Blueberry from $20.00 The Enchanted Berry - Strawberry from $17.00 Baked Nostalgia - Chocolate Chip Cookie from $24.00 Sugar Spell - Sugar Cookie from $24.00 Butterfly Biscuits $10.00 Vanilla Orchid - Vanilla from $15.00 Sugarlore Logo Unisex Soft Tee $15.00 Sipper Glass 16oz Cinnamon Queen Sugarlore Glass with Lid and Straw $19.99 Sipper Glass 16oz Sugar Spell Sugarlore Glass with Lid and Straw $19.99 Sugarlore Sugar Fiend Est 2025 Crewneck Sweatshirt $35.00 Sipper Glass 16oz Sugarlore Sugar Cauldron Glass with Lid and Straw $19.99 Sugarlore Logo Women's Cropped Tee $20.00 Sipper Glass 16oz Wicked Woods Sugarlore Glass with Lid and Straw $19.99 Eco Tote Bag - Sugarlore Sugar Fiend $29.99 Pet Bandana Collar - Sugarlore Cauldron from $23.48 Kitchen Tea Towel Sugarlore Cauldron Design $17.99 Sugarlore Cauldron Embroidered Beanie — Cozy Witchy Winter Hat $24.99 Peppermint Pixie Pink-Haired Sipper Glass — 16oz $19.99 Baked Nostalgia Magical Cookie 16oz Sipper Glass $19.99 Molasses Misadventure Holiday Mole 16oz Sipper Glass — Santa Hat & Ornament Design $19.99 Cat & Bread Loaf Tea Towel — Whimsical "The Dough Familiar" Kitchen Linen $17.99 Local pickup in Peoria, AZ is available on weekends unless otherwise arranged. Please reach out before ordering if you need a different pickup time.
