NOW TAKING ORDERS FOR OUR

Samhain Menu

available through October 31, order in half-dozen or dozen

Baked Nostalgia - Chocolate Chip Cookie Baked Nostalgia - Chocolate Chip Cookie Baked Nostalgia - Chocolate Chip Cookie
Baked Nostalgia - Chocolate Chip Cookie
from $24.00

Classic chocolate chip cookies with a twist. Made with brown butter, both semi-sweet and dark chocolate, and topped with sea salt.

Epic Bite Size: 4oz size for a more legendary indulgence

Cookies must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
After placing your order, we'll coordinate a day for pickup. If you need a different day, please reach out before ordering, and we’ll do our best to accommodate.

Sweater Weather - Pumpkin Coffee Cake Cookie
Sweater Weather - Pumpkin Coffee Cake Cookie
from $24.00

All the best parts of coffee cake in cookie form. Brown butter base, warm pumpkin spice, and a cinnamon streusel topping.

Epic Bite Size: 4oz size for a more legendary indulgence

Cookies must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
Spiced Hollows - Cookie Butter Stuffed Biscoff Cookie
Spiced Hollows - Cookie Butter Stuffed Biscoff Cookie
from $24.00

Spiced Biscoff brown butter cookie dough filled with a creamy cookie butter center, baked to perfection with a rich, gooey texture. Finished with a light crumble of Biscoff cookies.

Epic Bite Size: 4oz size for a more legendary indulgence

Cookies must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
After placing your order, we'll coordinate a day for pickup. If you need a different day, please reach out before ordering, and we’ll do our best to accommodate.
Raven's Roost - Brown Butter Chocolate Caramel Raven's Roost - Brown Butter Chocolate Caramel Raven's Roost - Brown Butter Chocolate Caramel
Raven's Roost - Brown Butter Chocolate Caramel
from $24.00

Our signature brown butter dough made with rich Dutch-processed cocoa powder, stuffed with Werther’s soft caramels, and topped with chocolate and flaky sea salt.

Epic Bite Size: 4oz size for a more legendary indulgence

Cookies must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

Sugar Spell - Sugar Cookie Sugar Spell - Sugar Cookie Sugar Spell - Sugar Cookie
Sugar Spell - Sugar Cookie
from $24.00

Soft vanilla sugar cookie with hints of almond, topped with icing and sprinkles. Icing color and sprinkles are seasonal colors (unless otherwise requested).

Epic Bite Size: 4oz size for a more legendary indulgence

Cookies must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
After placing your order, we'll coordinate a day for pickup. If you need a different day, please reach out before ordering, and we’ll do our best to accommodate.

Adventure Cookies

Adventure Cookies

Filters

Filters

Cookies & Screams - Oreo Cookies and Cream
from $24.00
Raven's Roost - Brown Butter Chocolate Caramel
from $24.00
March of the Mallows - Brown Butter S'mores Cookies
from $24.00
Sweater Weather - Pumpkin Coffee Cake Cookie
from $24.00
Raccoon Dream Pie - GF Oatmeal Cookie Sandwhich
from $24.00
Menagerie Dreams - Circus Animal Cookie
from $24.00
Popcorn Pigeon Party - Popcorn Caramel Cookie
from $24.00
Pride and Citrus - Stuffed Lemon Curd Cookie
from $24.00
Leo Delacroix - Coconut Rum Key Lime Cookie
from $24.00
The Strawberry Baker - Strawberry Shortcake Cookies
from $24.00
Lilyhearted - White Chocolate Matcha Frog Cookies
from $24.00
Sweet Solidarity - Kitchen Sink Cookie
from $24.00
Chapter & Crumbs
$20.00
Poppy Bear - Red Velvet White Chocolate Cookie
from $24.00
Sugarlore Baker's Choice Variety Pack
$24.00
The Candygram - M&M Candy Cookie
from $24.00
Pistachio Tree - Stuffed Pistachio Rose Cookie
from $24.00
Ichigo Tsukishiro – Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cookie
from $24.00
Butterbrew – Frosted Butterscotch Sugar Cookie
from $24.00
Noah Wilder – Malted Brown Butter Chocolate Chip with Walnuts
from $24.00
Toffee Harvest – Brown Butter Toffee Pecan Cookie
from $24.00
Sold Out
Pumpkin Patch - Pumpkindoodle Cookie
from $24.00
Heart of the Forest - Brown Butter Pecan Cookie
from $24.00
Spiced Hollows - Cookie Butter Stuffed Biscoff Cookie
from $24.00
Peppermint Hex - Peppermint Frosted Chocolate Sugar Cookie
from $24.00
Cranberry Solstice - White Chocolate Cranberry Cookie
from $24.00
Sugarlore Seasonal Variety Pack
$30.00
Molasses Misadventures - Chewy Molasses Cookie
from $24.00
Damien Hart – Dark Chocolate Espresso Cookie with Cayenne
from $24.00
Honey Hive - Spiced Honeydoodle Cookie
from $24.00
Fox's Folly - Reese's Peanut Butter Cookie
from $24.00
Banani Stefani - Banana Cream Pie Cookie
from $30.00
Baked Nostalgia - Chocolate Chip Cookie
from $24.00
Sugar Spell - Sugar Cookie
from $24.00

No results found

No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.

Local pickup in Peoria, AZ is available on weekends unless otherwise arranged. Please reach out before ordering if you need a different pickup time.